Double Dummy Analysis
Most hand records from a club or a tournament end with a small grid of numbers under each deal, and many players never look at it. That grid is double dummy analysis, a computer's count of the tricks the cards allowed when every hand is face up. Once you know what it measures and what it leaves out, it helps a lot when you go over the hands after the game.
What double dummy means
In bridge the dummy is the hand laid face up after the opening lead. From then on declarer sees two hands, their own and dummy, and each defender also sees two, their own and dummy. Players call this single dummy play. Double dummy play is the same game with all four hands visible, so nobody ever has to guess where a card is.
The term is older than bridge. In Victorian times double dummy was a form of whist for two players, each with an exposed hand as a partner, and it gave its name to a kind of puzzle. A double dummy problem shows all four hands and asks you to find the line that takes a stated number of tricks against any defense. The best known whist problem of this kind, by the Cambridge mathematician W. H. Whitfeld, appeared in the London magazine The Field in 1885. Seven years later the magazine Whist wrote that not one player in fifty could solve it without help.
Double dummy analysis applies the same idea to a real deal. A program tries the possible lines of play for both sides, assumes each side always finds its best card, and reports how many tricks declarer takes. The result depends only on the cards. The bidding and the players at the table play no part in it.
Reading a double dummy table
A solved deal is usually shown as a grid of twenty numbers, one for each of the four possible declarers in each of the five strains (notrump and the four suits). Each number is how many tricks that player would take as declarer in that strain, against perfect defense, with the opening lead coming from the player on declarer's left.
| Declarer | NT | ♠ | ♥ | ♦ | ♣ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| North | 10 | 11 | 8 | 7 | 9 |
| East | 3 | 2 | 5 | 6 | 4 |
| South | 10 | 11 | 7 | 7 | 9 |
| West | 3 | 2 | 5 | 6 | 4 |
Read across North's row. North takes eleven tricks in spades, so 4♠ makes with an overtrick and 6♠ goes one down. In notrump North takes ten tricks, enough for 3NT with one to spare. East and West never reach seven tricks in any strain, so they cannot make even a one-level contract.
North and South usually show the same numbers, because they hold the same cards between them. They can differ when the opening lead matters, since the leader changes with the declarer. Here North takes eight tricks in hearts and South only seven. When North declares, East makes the opening lead, and when South declares, West does, and the two leads are not worth the same to the defense.
Many hand records leave a cell blank when the number is below seven, since no contract can be made with fewer than seven tricks. Others print the highest level that makes instead of the trick count, so ten tricks in spades appears as 4♠.
How a computer solves a deal
Playing out every possible order of fifty-two cards would take far too long, even for a fast computer. Solvers reach the same exact answer by skipping the lines that cannot change it, mostly in four ways.
- Once the program has found a line that takes, say, ten tricks, it stops exploring any branch that is already shown to take fewer. This is the alpha-beta search used in chess programs as well.
- Before searching a position in depth, the solver counts the winners one side can cash straight away from the top. Often that count settles the position without further search.
- Different orders of play often reach the same position, so the solver stores positions it has already solved and looks them up. Matthew Ginsberg's partition search, built for his program GIB in the late 1990s, went a step further by storing whole groups of positions that differ only in small cards that cannot matter.
- The solver tries the likely best card first, such as a winner or a finesse. A good first guess finds the cutoffs early and saves most of the work.
Because nothing is left to chance, each number in the table is exact. The program has shown that declarer can take that many tricks against any defense and that the defense can hold declarer to it.
The free solver behind most bridge software today is DDS, which Bo Haglund released in 2006 and Søren Hein rebuilt in 2014. It is open source, and on a modern computer it fills a whole table in a fraction of a second. ACBL tournament hand records have long printed their makeable contracts from another program, Deep Finesse, written by Bill Bailey. The BridgeTricks double dummy solver runs its search in your browser.
Par: the best result for both sides
Par is the score a deal is worth when both sides bid as well as they play, using the double dummy table. The side that can make the higher contract bids it. The other side then asks whether a doubled sacrifice would cost less than letting that contract make, and if it would, the sacrifice is par.
On the deal above, North-South can make 4♠ with an overtrick. East-West have no sensible sacrifice: their best strain, diamonds, takes six tricks, so 5♦ doubled would go five down for 1,100 when they are not vulnerable, far more than the game is worth. Par is 4♠ by North-South, scored as +450 when they are not vulnerable and +650 when they are.
Par is a yardstick for discussion, and some par contracts are ones nobody would bid at the table. It is most useful on competitive deals, where it shows which side should have bought the contract and whether a sacrifice was worth taking.
Where you meet double dummy figures
- Clubs and tournaments print the makeable contracts under each deal, so after a session you can check whether the game your side missed was really there.
- Bridge sites let you replay a finished board with the double dummy result beside each card, which shows the exact trick where a contract was lost.
- To learn how often a contract makes, deal thousands of hands that fit the auction and solve each one. The law of total tricks page tests the law on ten thousand deals solved this way, and the BridgeTricks Lead Trainer grades each opening lead by solving it on thousands of layouts.
- David Bird and Taf Anthias built Winning Notrump Leads (2011) by solving thousands of deals for each lead problem double dummy and comparing how often each lead beat the contract.
Using the table after a session
The table is most helpful when you read it as a record of what the cards allowed, then ask what a player could have known. A contract you went down in may have been makeable only by guessing a queen, and a contract you made against the odds may have been handed to you by the opening lead.
- 1.Find the contract you played and compare your tricks with the table.
- 2.If you took fewer, replay the deal and look for the trick where the count dropped.
- 3.Ask whether the winning line needed information you did not have, such as the position of a missing queen.
- 4.Look at the contracts your side did not bid. A slam or game in the table is worth a talk about the auction.
- 5.If you took more tricks than the table shows, the defense gave you something, often with the opening lead.
Real play and double dummy differ most on the opening lead and in slams. The page on the limits of double dummy analysis has the figures.
Common questions
Short answers to what readers ask most.
- What does double dummy mean in bridge?
- It means play with all four hands face up, so every player knows where every card is. A double dummy result is the number of tricks declarer takes when both sides play perfectly with that knowledge.
- What is the difference between single dummy and double dummy?
- Single dummy is real bridge, where you see your own hand and dummy and have to work out the rest. Double dummy assumes everyone sees all the cards, so there are no guesses and no deception.
- Is double dummy analysis always right?
- It is exact for the cards as they lay, because the program proves each number in the table. What it cannot tell you is whether a player who could not see the cards would have found the same line.
- Why do North and South show different numbers?
- The opening lead comes from declarer's left, so a different player leads when the other partner declares. When one lead costs the defense a trick and the other does not, the two rows differ.
- What is par in bridge?
- Par is the score both sides would reach with perfect bidding and perfect play: the higher contract that makes, or a doubled sacrifice over it when that costs less.
- How long does a computer take to solve a deal?
- A full table of twenty results takes a fraction of a second on a modern computer with a solver such as DDS. Simulations of thousands of deals are practical because of that speed.
Practice: double dummy analysis
Eight quick questions on what you just read. For a longer session, take the hundred-question quiz.
